Category Archives: Birth Center

Exploring Your Options Series – Part 5

Deciding on a place of birth is simple for most women. Most women choose to give birth in a hospital. Women generally feel safe in a hospital. Are there any other safe options? Is it safe to give birth out of the hospital? YES! Studies show that out of hospital options, such as a birth center or at home, are safe for low risk women.

I would encourage you to consider and research the different options and their safety before coming to a conclusion about where to have your baby. The location of your birth will determine what other options are available to you. Some links to help with your research Science and Sensibility “Is Home Birth Reasonable Option?”Science and Sensibility “Birth Outcomes by Birth Location”Science and Sensibility “Flaws In Recent Home Birth Research”, Science and Sensibility – “Obstetricians Claim Homebirth is Unsafe…Again. Where’s The Evidence?”

Part of the decision making process should include weighing the pros and cons of each birth place. Previous decisions (ie: deciding on a care provider) will also have an influence on where you give birth. If you want a physician to attend your birth, having a home birth may not be an option. Not many physicians attend home births, but there are some. I am not sure there are any in Utah, though.

Below are some pros and cons I came up with. Because everyone is different and there is no one right answer for anyone, these things may not apply to your situation. Feel free to make your own pros and cons list to figure out what is the best option for you. Where you feel the most comfortable and safest will be the best place for you to give birth.

Most women in this area plan to have a hospital birth and never consider a birth center or home birth. I would encourage you to consider and research the different options and their safety before coming to a conclusion about where to have your baby. The location of your birth will determine what other options are available to you.

  • Hospital
    • Pros –
      • Specialized care for high-risk pregnancies and births.
      • Pain medication readily available
      • A nurse to take care of you and baby, meals brought to you
    • Cons –
      • Birth is seen as a medical crisis.
      • Mother and baby are often separated
      • Difficulties are often resolved with medications and high-tech procedures
      • Standardized care rather than individualized.
      • Often noisy, lack of privacy, strangers (the nurses are likely people you will not have met prior to your birth. Your particular doctor or midwife may not be the one to attend the birth)
      • Institutional feel.
      • Understaffed.
      • Higher risk of infection.
      • Have to pack and travel to birth place
  • Birth Center
    • Pros –
      • Less infection risk than hospital.
      • Midwifery Care Model
      • More home like than hospital
      • Most problems that arise can be dealt with on location.
      • Baby is never separated from the mother
      • Continuous support
    • Cons –
      • Have to pack and travel to birth place
      • Higher transfer rate than home birth.
      • Fewer pain medication options available
  • Home
    • Pros –
      • Your own space/Familiarity
      • Midwifery Care Model
      • Low-risk treatments used to resolve issues that may arise.
      • One-on-one care with your chosen birth attendant (although this isn’t always the case now. There are some homebirth midwives in the area that have a “practice” much like doctors)
      • Individualized care.
      • Continuous support
    • Cons –
      • Arrange for someone to take care of mom’s needs, the home, and other children.
      • No pain medications available
      • May need to transfer if difficulties arise.

Part 1 | Part 2 | Part 3 | Part 4

Share this post:
Facebook Twitter Email Pinterest Reddit Linkedin

Birth Center Birth

I had the lovely opportunity of supporting a mom during the birth of her first baby.  Mom chose to give birth at Great Expectations Birth Care in Murray, Utah.

Share this post:
Facebook Twitter Email Pinterest Reddit Linkedin